Back to the catalogue

Review a task and prepare useful feedback with AI

A workflow for checking criteria, examining fictional answers and writing feedback that guides the next step.

A pencil draws a stepping-stone bridge between two sheets.

Cover image generated with AI for Ed-IA.

What you will do

Prepare feedback on an explanation about energy. AI will help organise observations and suggest questions; the teacher makes the judgement. A fictional answer lets you practise without using personal student data.

Set criteria before reading the answer

The task asks why a bicycle stops when braking. Look for decreasing kinetic energy, a connection to increasing internal energy, and reasoning that explains the phenomenon. Share age-appropriate criteria when you set the task.

CriterionEvidence to look for
Energy changeExplains that energy associated with motion decreases.
Physical connectionConnects braking with warming brakes and surroundings.
ReasoningLinks before and after without making energy disappear.
PROMPT

Analyse this fictional answer against three criteria: energy change, connection to warming, and justification. Quote only wording actually present. Separate observations from possible interpretations. Do not assign a mark or infer ability or effort. Suggest one short question to check understanding. Answer: “The bicycle stops because the brakes use up all the energy. When none is left, it stops moving.”

AI assistant · demonstrationEd-IA
Analyse this fictional answer without a mark: “The bicycle stops because the brakes use up all the energy.” Give one text-based observation and a question about warming brakes.
IA
Observation

The answer says “use up all the energy”. It does not mention warming.

Next question: how would you explain the brakes becoming warm?
Educational conversation recreation with example data and a written sample response. Real interfaces and responses may differ.

Check every observation

Compare the model’s claims with the original wording. If it says the answer mentions heat, reject that claim: it does not. Do not conclude that the learner misunderstands energy conservation in every setting. Ask a question or collect a second piece of evidence.

Turn feedback into an action

Possible feedback: “You connected braking with stopping. Revisit the idea that energy disappears. What would warming brakes tell us? Rewrite your explanation linking the decrease in movement with that effect.” This leaves the learner a specific next step.

PROMPT

Write feedback in no more than four sentences. Recognise one idea present, identify what needs revisiting and suggest a specific action. Do not praise things you cannot observe. Do not provide a complete answer to copy.

Check whether it helps

Ask for a revised explanation or a short oral response. Compare the versions: did only the wording change, or are the concepts connected more clearly? Keep any necessary evidence in the school’s systems. Better-sounding feedback does not itself prove improved learning.

Check the result

Ed-IA / César Bosch
Resources & appsDownload the template