Back to the catalogue

When a correct answer is not enough

How can we collect evidence of reasoning and use AI to prepare questions and feedback while retaining teacher judgement?

A perfect paper sphere reveals a fragile inner structure.

Cover image generated with AI for Ed-IA.

The product tells part of the story

A polished answer may present a coherent explanation. Understanding also becomes visible in justification, responses to changed conditions and revision after a question. This need predates AI; easy access to convincing text makes it more apparent.

Define the evidence you need

For applying a physical relationship, ask learners to explain a choice before calculating. For comparing sources, examine why one was selected and another rejected. The task must make those decisions visible. A written justification may help, although AI can generate that too.

Combine manageable moments

You do not need a lengthy interview after every activity. Choose a meaningful task and combine an individual first attempt in class, a short question and a revision. Make the approach compatible with available time and learners’ access and communication needs.

MomentWhat it can show
First attemptA starting point under stated conditions.
Question about a decisionEvidence of a particular connection or choice.
Later revisionHow a challenge or hint is incorporated.
AI assistant · demonstrationEd-IA
Analyse this fictional answer without a mark: “The bicycle stops because the brakes use up all the energy.” Give one text-based observation and a question about warming brakes.
IA
Observation

The answer says “use up all the energy”. It does not mention warming.

Next question: how would you explain the brakes becoming warm?
Educational conversation recreation with example data and a written sample response. Real interfaces and responses may differ.

A useful role for AI

It can suggest follow-up questions, identify ambiguous rubric wording or draft feedback from teacher observations. Ask, for example, for two questions that distinguish repeating a definition from applying it in a new context. Check whether the questions actually make that distinction observable.

PROMPT

Given this learning objective and fictional answer, suggest two short questions that reveal reasoning. Explain what evidence each might provide and what cannot be concluded. Do not infer authorship, effort or ability. Do not assign a mark.

A wooden bridge with a plank set aside reveals its supports.
Making reasoning visible helps us interpret the result.Conceptual illustration generated with AI.

Keep conclusions proportionate

An incomplete answer does not describe a learner’s overall ability. A fluent oral explanation does not establish every aspect of learning either. Interpret evidence against the task, conditions and other observations. Suspecting tool use is not a substitute for this work.

One change to begin with

Review an activity and identify the evidence missing from your judgement of its objective. Add one question or revision opportunity that might provide it. The feedback guide explains how to turn an observation into support learners can act on.

Ed-IA / César Bosch